Which One is the Best Gotham Steel Pan?
If you simply want to test out the non-stick wonder of Gotham Steel Pan Reviews, check out the GOTHAM STEEL 9.5 inches Non-stick Titanium Frying Pan by Daniel Green. However, if you are looking for the best bang for your buck, the Gotham Steel 10-Piece Kitchen Nonstick Frying Pan and Cookware Set features a variety of pans for a remarkably good price point.
High-quality pans should be robust, shatterproof, free of chemicals, versatile, and best of all, non-stick. You don’t want to have to use oil or butter, unless you want to for the flavor. And the very best steel pans should be attractive too, so that you can proudly display them in your kitchen.
They should also enhance the flavor of the food you make so that you get more taste for your efforts. You want to show off your very best recipes in the best cookware that makes them shine.
The best Gotham steel pans promise to fulfill all of these criteria. But are they really as good as they say they are? And which one is best for you?
In this review, we have done all the painstaking research so you don’t have too. Here is our Gotham steel pans review for the very best of them on the market today.
- Things To Consider Before Buying
- How To Cook In A Gotham Steel Pan
- Gotham Steel VS Red Copper Vs Copper Chef
- Best Gotham Steel Pan Comparisons
- Top 10 Gotham Steel Pans
- Our Recommendation
Things to Consider Before Buying Gotham Steel Pan
The Gotham Steel pan is probably at least a bit different from other pans you have used before, but like every other pan and dish choice, there are things to consider. These considerations revolve solely around your individual and/or family needs.
Do you need a set or a single pan?
The first thing to consider is whether you want or need only one pan or a set. The Gotham Steel pan comes in a few different options. A single 9.5-inch pan can be purchased if that is all you need. At times, they offer double this giving you two 9.5-inch pans.
Next is a 7 piece set that includes a deep square pan, a steamer tray, a mesh basket, a recipe book, a 12.5-inch pan, and two 9.5-inch pans.
The largest offer is a 10 piece set that comes with an 8.5-inch fry pan, a 9.5-inch fry pan, a 10.25-inch fry pan with lid, a 1.5-quart pot with lid, a 2.5-quart pot with lid, a 5-quart pot with lid, and a stainless steel steamer insert.
All of these sets are nonstick and non-scratch. With these multiple options, the choice comes down to how much you would like to replace in your kitchen.
What size, shape, and depth of cookware do you need?
You should also consider what particular types of cookware you need, meaning what size, shape, and depth do you need to cook your favorite meals.
Do you only pan-fry a couple of things? Do you bake a great deal? Do you steam a lot of your food? How many people do you cook for? How many pots do you usually need and what size are they?
From the sets listed above, you can see that Gotham Steel has a pot or pan for pretty much anything.
Consider what types of food you will be cooking in them, how you will be cooking them, and how much you will be cooking.
The answers to these questions should help you determine the size, shape, and depth of the pots and pans you purchase.
Is the cookware compatible with your stove?
In order to make sure that you do not waste your money or time on useless cookware, you need to make sure that your pots and pans will work with your equipment.
For instance, not all cookware works well on induction stovetops. There seems to be a difference in opinion about the Gotham Steel pan in this area as the company says that it will work on induction stovetops but some reviews state that the opposite is actually true.
With this in mind, if you have an induction stove top and wish to try the pan, purchase with care and make your own decision in regards to this matter.
As the website offers a 90-day money back guarantee, you have plenty of time to test it on your oven and get a refund if it does not work as claimed.
How to Cook in a Gotham Steel Pan
Cooking with a Gotham Steel pan is simple and offers versatility, but there are some things that users need to know.
First and foremost, always read instructions that may be included and practice kitchen safety. One of the selling points of this pan is that there is no oil or butter needed to coat the pan for cooking.
There are warnings to never spray the pan with cooking spray as this can affect the coating. Additionally, since olive oil has such a low flash point, it is advised to not use olive oil at all in it.
Though the advertisement shows that you can beat eggs in the pan without damaging it, it is probably wise to do any chopping and slicing outside of the pan for the sake of the pan’s coating and your safety.
This Gotham Steel pan can be used to cook pretty much anything, whether you are cooking a steak, eggs, omelets, melting cheese or anything else your heart desires.
This cookware can also be used in the oven up to 500°. Never heat the pan empty. After each use, wipe away any oil, food or debris with a paper towel.
If needed, dish soap and warm water can be used. Although oil or butter is not needed on a regular basis, it is important to maintain the quality of the service in a process known as seasoning your pan. Doing this a couple of times per year will usually be enough.
The Gotham Steel Pan is made with an aluminum core, which heats quickly and evenly. If you have not used a them or are not familiar with cooking with this type of material, it is best to start off by cooking at about half of the temperature that you are used to.
If you normally make your eggs on medium, start with low to feel out your new cookware. You will likely find that you will have to adjust all or most of your cooking temps.
Gotham Steel VS Red Copper VS Copper Chef
Three of the most popular pans at this time are the Gotham Steel pan, the Red Copper pan, and the Copper Chef pan. With all the talk and the lists of features and benefits, how do you know which one to purchase? Let’s look at the differences and similarities between the three options.
First, we will discuss the similarities. All three of these pans have nonstick surfaces that do not include Teflon, so they are free of toxins making them much safer to use. This also reduces the risk of the surface chipping and peeling off into your food.
The Copper Chef can withstand the highest temperature (850°) while both the Gotham Steel and Red Copper pans can withstand a maximum temperature of 500°.
Additionally, the Copper Chef has deeper sides than its two competitors although the Red Copper pan has a wider cooking surface.
Other differences revolve around what materials each pan is made with. The Copper Chef pan has a layer of copper pressed in between stainless steel and aluminum layers and a ceramic coating.
They are made with stainless steel, high-quality titanium, and ceramic with an aluminum core which, like copper, heats quickly and evenly. The inside is coated with titanium infused ceramic.
The Red Copper pan is made from copper and ceramic with a copper-infused ceramic coating. All three of these popular pans have great features and benefits. Each offers different size cooking surfaces and are durable.
The titanium of the Gotham Steel pan makes it stand up against wear and tear a little better than the others though they offer larger cooking space. Choosing between them will come down to personal choice and individual needs.
What is it made out of?
Teflon non-stick pans are now a thing of the past. Ceramic coated pans are taking the frying pan world by storm.
Gotham Steel Pans say that their pan is made out of titanium for superior even-heating and warp-resistant performance and then the interior is coated with nearly indestructible ceramic.
They show the TV chef using whisks, metal spatulas and even electric blenders on the surface without causing a scratch. In fact, they advertise it is a non-scratch product.
Do They Require Seasoning?
If you cruise the internet, you will find demonstrations of eggs sliding across the pan’ surface like a skate on ice. The manufacturer says you won’t need any kind of added oil or fat to have your food slip out without leaving behind any burnt bits.
The ceramic surface won’t scrape off, either, making it a more durable option to the aging Teflon pan industry. There is no indication the pan requires any kind of seasoning or preparation to maintain the non-stick qualities.
Can I Use the Gotham Steel Pan in an Oven or Induction Top?
All of the items we mention in this article can be used in an oven, up to 500 degrees F. All of them can be used on gas and electric stovetops, and the items that can be used on an induction top are the Gotham Steel Hard Anodized Fry Pan Premium Skillet Set, and the GOTHAM STEEL Hammered Pan with Tempered Glass Lid.
Which is Better, Gotham Steel or Blue Diamond?
Overall, Gotham steel will give you better quality, as the coating is done three times and it is more long-lasting. The heat distribution is also superior, and the pans will last a lifetime if you care for them well.
Blue Diamond cookware doesn’t tend to remain non-stick forever – the coating will eventually start to flake off and perhaps get into your food. The heat distribution is not as even, the non-stick coating is very thin, and the pan itself can start to warp after use.
Is it safe to use?
Gotham Steel Pans are rated oven safe up to 500F with metal handles, instead of soft silicone or other plastics that will melt.
This makes searing your roast and transferring it to the oven for finishing a breeze. Glass lids are not rated oven safe, and you’ll have to use your good old fashioned aluminum foil to cover the larger pans in the oven.
Are Gotham Steel Pans PTFE/PFOA/PFOS Free?
Best of all, by eliminating all plastics from the cooking surfaces, Gotham Steel Pans have no toxic chemicals that can leach into your carefully prepared meals.
You’ll be able to cook for your family knowing that you are not adding potential carcinogens to their food.
No other cookware set ever make any statement like this before in their website. The manufacturer is putting their reputation on the line guaranteeing you are using a safe, clean pan.
Best Gotham Steel Pan Comparisons
1. Gotham Steel 9.5 Ultra Nonstick Ceramic Copper (Best overall)
A beautifully crafted fry pan with a gorgeous handle and super slick ceramic surface that allows you to slide your favorite fried foods from the pan to your plate with a flick of your wrist.
|Read Our Review|
2. Gotham Steel Pots and Pans 10 Piece Cookware Set
This attractive 10-piece cookware set contains everything you need for the kitchen, with two lightweight frying pans, two handy sauce pans, a large stock pot, glass lids, and a steamer.
|Read Our Review|
Perfect for searing steaks, bacon, chicken, as well as grilling burgers, while its bottom ridges drain away fat and add attractive sear marks to food for that fresh-off-the-barbecue look and taste.
|Read Our Review|
This 12-inch fry pan is lightweight and easy to use, while being both oven and dishwasher safe. Perfect for any level chef with its stay-cool handles and handy scratch-proof surface.
|Read Our Review|
This handy set includes a deep square pan with lid, a 12.5-inch fry pan, a 9.5-inch fry pan, and a steamer tray, all of which are non-stick and free from chemicals.
|Read Our Review|
This beautifully hammered, non-stick, copper-style pan allows for even surface heating and therefore delicious meals. The pan is suitable for not only the oven, but for all stovetops, including induction. Includes glass lid.
|Read Our Review|
This durable and dishwasher-safe double grill is suitable for grilling all types of foods, both indoors and outdoors. Works with electric, gas, and glass stovetops, as well as with propane and gas grills.
|Read Our Review|
This practical fry pan has an enamel exterior finish, and allows you to prepare foods without oil or butter. It is suitable for use in the oven, and on electric and gas stoves.
|Read Our Review|
This set consists of two frying pans: 9.75 and 11.3 inches. Both feature the nonstick ceramic and titanium coating that is sturdy and dishwasher safe, and handles that stay cool on the stovetop.
|Read Our Review|
This attractive set is perfect for personal use for meals for one, as it features a small fry pan, a sauce pan with lid, a wok, and a griddle pan.
|Read Our Review|
Top 10 Gotham Steel Pans
We’ve written a Gotham Steel Pan Reviews to help you figure out which pan will work best for you. Read on to find out which one you might want to spend your hard earned cash on.
This is the pan that is the star of all the infomercials, thus making it the most popular purchase of all the Gotham Steel pans. The 9.5-inch skillet is sized to make an omelet or other one or two serving meal.
It is light, so easy to maneuver about the stovetop. It has been demonstrated to be non-stick and durable enough to handle metal utensils without scratching. While it is listed as dishwasher friendly, you can literally wipe it down with a paper towel between uses.
There are plenty of detractors out there, so if you want to test out the Gotham Steel claims yourself, this is the one to start with.
- Non-scratch technology
- Ovenproof up to 500F
- Dishwasher safe
- Inconsistent Performance among users
- Small Pan
- Does Not Work on Induction Cooktops
This square grill pan appears to be the favorite among Gotham Steel fans. It is a convenient square shape, allowing the cook to position four burgers or chops in it without the crowding that a 10-inch skillet would have.
The bottom is ribbed to create attractive grill marks on your steaks and features the non-stick and non-scratch surface the infomercials love to demonstrate on its standard skillet cousin.
It does not come with a lid, is only rated up to 425F instead of 500F and the purchase link has the wrong product description on it. This is not a griddle, although Gotham Steel does make one of those.
- Large square cooking surface
- Works well with burgers and fatty meats
- Leaves attractive grill marks on food
- Product description on purchase page is incorrect
- Low sides
- Only Heat tolerant up to 425F
This set is the one you want once you are convinced that Gotham Steel Pans are for you! The set has a very attractive low price for the number of pans that you receive.
It includes the small 8.5-inch skillet, a 10.5-inch skillet with a lid, 1.5-quart pot with lid, 2.5-quart pot with lid, and a 5-quart pot with 5-quart steamer insert and lid.
You’ll be loaded up with pans that will help you cook up a single egg or steam up a pot of clams. For the price, you won’t find another non-stick set able to compete with this unless you find a cut-rate brand.
It should be noted that the instructions for seasoning must be followed when you receive the pans and the copperish color is subject to discoloration after repeated heat cycles.
- Large variety of pans for multiple uses
- Low price for number of pans
- Non-stick cookware
- Must be seasoned and maintained
- Lids are not oven safe
- Pans can discolor after use
Have you always wanted a pan that can sear a large roast or steak and then transfer into the oven? This is it.
The extra large 12.5-inch skillet has a metal handle and all metal rivets such it can be used as either on the stovetop or the oven to bake.
The small helper handle makes it easier to lift heavy dishes in and out of the oven without putting your thumb in the food.
It is priced quite a bit higher than the rest of the line, and you’ll spend as much for a professional-grade pan. Also, if you intend to use it primarily on the cooktop, know that smaller burners will create cool spots on the pan as it has a large bottom surface.
This pan will work better on your extra large burners. It is not designed for induction cooktops.
- Extra large pan great for preparing large steaks/hams
- Small helper handle
- Oven proof up to 500F
- High price for questionable performance
- Lightweight construction feels cheap
- Smaller burners create cold spots
For the frying maniac, there is nothing worse than a deep fryer that ends up with a sticky build up that is nearly impossible to remove. This set is made for you.
The extra deep square pan includes a lid, fry basket and steamer tray. You’ll be able to cook french fries, hush puppies, fried chicken and a nice fish fry without effort. You also receive the signature 9.5-inch skillet and the extra large 12.5-inch skillet, making this the set for the super sized family.
The price on this set is alarmingly high and it might be an item that you would want to watch for bargain offers. Sometimes the bundle seems to be missing parts, but customer service will fix any deficiencies. Finally, make sure you season the pans properly before use to avoid disappointment.
- Deep square pan great for deep frying
- Extra large skillet cooks up big meals
- Small skillet perfect for a couple eggs
- Expensive three pan set
- Packaging may be missing parts
- Requires seasoning–not maintenance free
You will love how this pan looks! Its hammered copper exterior is just gorgeous and means you could even serve your guests directly from the pan (paella, anyone?).
Its handy lid means food can cook evenly while moisture doesn’t escape. No matter how many times you use it, if you care for it, this non stick pan will look good as new. This large Gotham steel pan is 9.5 inches in diameter and comes with a fitted glass lid.
It features a non stick coating that is scratch resistant, even when using metal utensils, and you can enjoy cooking without oil or butter. It’s oven safe too. You can use this on all stovetops, even induction. It’s also lightweight, weighing just 1 pound.
Oven safe: You can prepare meals on the stove and then finish them off in the oven, up to 500 degrees F.
Dishwasher safe: Easy to clean, just put it in the dishwasher with no need for scrubbing.
Stay-cool handle: No need for gloves when cooking on the stove.
- A frying pan that you can use without oil and on both the stovetop and in the oven.
- Burned food may take longer to remove.
This double grill set means you can prepare healthy barbecues either indoors or outdoors. Food will be attractively seared thanks to the deep ridges, and any excess grease is caught in the dips around the edges.
You don’t have to worry about grease dripping onto your stovetop or grill, and you can simply pop these grills into your dishwasher when you’re finished.
The sturdy, non-stick surface means you can leave the butter in the refrigerator – no need for oils unless you want them. Any kind of utensils are suitable, even metal utensils, as the coating of the grills is scratch-resistant, reinforced with titanium and ceramic, and is 100% free from PFOA, cadmium, lead & other harmful chemicals.
Suits gas and propane grills: You can prepare meals outdoors easily, with no need for harsh scrubbing of a traditional grill.
Even heat distribution: No hot spots or dead zones, meaning your food is perfectly cooked every time.
Easy cleanup: Put your grills right into the dishwasher when you’ve finished cooking.
- A grill set that you can use indoors and outdoors for a barbecue that’s much easier to clean up than traditional setups.
- Total surface area may be smaller than what you need: each grill measures 12.4 x 11.41 x 0.59 inches.
You will love the look of this pan with its beautiful enamel outside finish and its golden brown interior. The pan is 12.5 inches in diameter, so plenty of room for one-pot meals, and the handy lid keeps your food warm and prevents spattering on your stovetop.
The handle is attractively finished and is double-riveted and contoured, and the pan can be used on electric and gas stovetops.
Non stick pan has a scratch-resistant surface and delivers rapid, even heating for consistent cooking results every time. Your favorite recipes will always come out just the way you want them to. Not only is there no need for oil or butter, but you can use this pan in the oven as well. Cleanup is easy, as the pan can go in the dishwasher.
Versatile: This item can be used both indoors and outdoors, as it can withstand heat up to 500 degrees F.
Strong: Made with ceramic and super strong titanium, people say that cooking with these pans is like cooking on air. The pans are lightweight too, and no need to worry about only using wooden utensils, as the surface is scratch-resistant.
Non-stick: The ti cerama inside means it’s easy to transfer food from the stove to your plate: just tip the pan and voila! Eggs, steaks, stews, anything you make can be plated up in a snap.
- An attractive pan that works anywhere and cooks your dishes evenly every time.
- Could be a bit larger, as you’ll want to use this a lot!
These pans are simply gorgeous and look great as a set together. You will love having two sizes to play with, and that they are highly wear-resistant and offer perfectly even heat distribution, giving you professional results in the kitchen.
No oil or butter means healthier eating, too. Both pans feature the ultra-sturdy, ceramic and titanium coating. They are oven safe, so you can prepare dishes in many different ways. They are also dishwasher friendly, making cleanup easy.
They even are suitable for use on induction stovetops in addition to gas and electric stovetops. The pans are two different sizes: 9.75 and 11.3 inches in diameter.
Hard surface: The hard anodized aluminum exterior is sturdy, dense, and non-porous. The ti cerama coating inside is reinforced with ceramic and titanium and has been coated three times. Metal spatulas, whisks, and other metal tools can be used without fear of scratches.
Professional: The superior method of heat distribution means that your recipes will come out exactly the same every time, with no risks of undercooking or overcooking food. Make sure you make the most of these pans!
Stay-cool handles: Cookware with stay-cool handles means you don’t need to worry about burning yourself when picking up your dishes from the stove. You can carry them directly from the stove to the table easily – particularly as both are also lightweight.
- These pans look beautiful and the two different sizes means you can use them for everything you’d want to fry, sauté, or simmer.
- There are only two! Both are shallow, so if you want something deeper, you’ll need to buy that separately, or choose another set (see below).
You will love that this set of Gotham steel pans has everything you need to make breakfast, lunch, and dinner. From pancakes or oatmeal to fried eggs and Chinese food, you can do it all with this set!
The set also looks fantastic, since everything matches with the same lovely copper-colored interior and hard-wearing black exterior.
This mini 5-piece set comes with a 6.5-inch mini fry pan, a 6-inch square griddle, a 0.75 quart saucepan with its tempered glass lid, and a 5.75-inch wok. Everything has rubber-grip handles that are ergonomic and make cooking easy and comfortable. Each item in the set also nests inside each other, making storage a breeze.
Easy storage: When you’re living on your own, space is often at a premium, so you can save lots of cupboard space with this set.
Single serve: The sizes of each item are designed for making single servings, which means you don’t have to use large pots with just a small amount of food at the bottom! This set is designed exclusively for one to two-portion meal prep.
Healthy: The non-toxic ti cerama coating makes these items free from PFOA, PFOS, lead or cadmium. And because you can cook without oil or butter, your meals can be low-fat, too.
- A very attractive set that does just about anything you want to do in the kitchen.
- The set only suits meals for one or two people, so you can’t batch cook.
Our Recommendation For The Best Gotham Steel Pan
Our favorite Gotham steel pan set isthe Gotham Steel 10-Piece Kitchen Nonstick Frying Pan and Cookware Set, as it contains everything you need. You’ll get the lasting quality, the even heat distribution, the cold handles, and the beautiful look, while getting a highly practical assortment of pots and pans, all of which are oven safe and dishwasher friendly.
If you are cooking for one or two people, you may prefer the Gotham Steel Mini Stackmaster 5 Piece Cookware Set, as you can make smaller portions and still reap all the benefits of a multi-piece set of cookware that will last you a lifetime.
We hope this list of Gotham steel cookware has helped you to make the best choice for your needs and for your budget.
We hope you enjoyed reading our Gotham Steel Pans Review and Buying Guide and that it helped you decide which one is right for you.
Please feel free to share your thoughts and experiences in the comments section below or share the buying guide with your friends on your social media page!
Gotham Steel Pan Tested by Experts:
- Fox News: Do the Gotham Steel Pans really work?
- ‘Buy It and Try It’: Gotham Steel Pan
- KY3’s Ethan Forhetz and Lisa Rose test the “Gotham Steel” pan.