What is the Best Yogurt Maker?
We have picked the Cuisinart CYM-100 Electronic Yogurt Maker with Automatic Cooling as the top yogurt maker as it has the capacity to make 50 ounces of yogurt at a time, has an auto cooling feature, and an easy to read display. All of its non-electrical parts are dishwasher safe, and it comes with a three-year warranty.
For those who love eating yogurt, you may find yourself spending more and more money as yogurt prices, especially Greek yogurt, continue to rise. If you are not willing to give up your yogurt, there is another solution: an at home yogurt maker.
These kitchen appliances give you the ability to eat as much yogurt as you want at just a fraction of the price. In this article, we will take a look at what we consider to be the top yogurt maker and seven other models.
Top 8 Best Yogurt Makers: Our Picks & Recommendations
- Best Overall: Cuisinart CYM-100 Electronic Yogurt Maker
- Best Budget: Euro Cuisine YM80 Yogurt Maker
- Runner-Up (Best Budget): The Dash Greek Yogurt Maker
- Best Electric Yogurt Maker: Yogourmet 104 Electric Yogurt Maker
- Best Manual Yogurt Maker: Oster Mykonos Greek Manual Yogurt Maker
- Best Stainless Steel Yogurt Maker: VitaClay VS7600-2C 2-In-1 Yogurt Maker
- Best Large Yogurt Maker: Euro Cuisine YM100 Automatic Yogurt Maker
- Best Small Yogurt Maker: Salton YM9 1-Quart Yogurt Maker
Why Would You Need a Yogurt Maker in Your Kitchen?
The answer to this question can be summed up in just a few words for yogurt lovers: time, money, health, and versatility. Let’s start with time.
Making yogurt at home can save a lot of time and energy spent going to the market- something that almost no one enjoys.
In fact, some people avoid the market at all costs until it is absolutely necessary to go. For yogurt lovers, this may lead to being without this beloved food item.
For something that comes in such tiny containers, you would think that yogurt does not cost much, but that simply is not true.
Sure, a container or two will not break the bank, but if you eat a lot of yogurt, you are spending your hard earned money on something you can make for much cheaper at home.
Like other processed foods, store bought yogurt can have a lot of preservatives and additives in it. With yogurt meant to be a healthy food, it is counterproductive to eat yogurt with said preservatives.
However, when you make it at home, you can add your own ingredients and keep it all natural. Additionally, when you make it yourself, you know exactly what is put in it.
Finally, there is the versatility that a yogurt maker offers. You can make any flavor yogurt you want, in as many combinations as you want. You are not limited to what the stores offer, and you do not have to drive across town to find the flavor that you love.
Your options are only limited to your imagination and ingredients when you use a yogurt maker. Any of these reasons alone is a great reason to use an at home yogurt maker, but all of them added together makes it a very wise choice.
How to Choose the Right Yogurt Maker?
When you are ready to purchase a yogurt maker, there are certain factors to consider.
The Materials Used:
You will often find yogurt makers designed with BPA free plastic or stainless steel. Stainless steel does look better and is more durable. However, fingerprints are difficult to get rid of on stainless steel, so plastic yogurt makers are easier to clean.
There are both electric and manual yogurt makers. As you can imagine, electric models generally cost more, but they are much more convenient.
You simply have to add the ingredients, press a button, and let the yogurt maker do its job. The timer will go off when the process is finished. Manual yogurt makers mean that you have more work to do.
First and foremost, a timer on a yogurt maker is of great importance. Without one, you may mess up your yogurt batch and have to start all over.
Second, different yogurt makers’ timers do different things, such as switch off the fermenting when time is up. Check your recipe to determine what type of timer you need to search for.
Different yogurt makers can handle different amounts of yogurt. For instance, some may only allow you to make large quantities of one flavor, while another lets you make multiple flavors in small quantities.
The capacity you choose should rely specifically on how much yogurt you desire to make.
The pots are generally glass or plastic, including BPA free plastic. However, glass is guaranteed to be BPA free and will not break down as plastics pots will.
Temperature control is important in a yogurt maker for two reasons. The first is that you want your yogurt to cook consistently throughout the entire cooking process.
Second, an automated chilling feature makes sure that your yogurt does not ruin if you cannot get to it fast enough.
There are many options when it comes to the design of a yogurt maker. First, there is the size. You can purchase very small or much larger devices, as well as the previously mentioned plastic and stainless steel.
They might be taller and skinny or shorter and wide. Some look sleek and more while some look more traditional. The design you choose is a strictly personal decision.
Easy to Use:
No one wants to have a contraption that requires a rocket scientist to operate- except perhaps a rocket scientist. Part of the allure of a yogurt maker, especially an electric one, is the convenience that they provide. If it is difficult to operate, it defeats the purpose.
Unfortunately, even the best product can have a defect. You should never buy a product that does not give a warranty with the product. A warranty of at least one year is ideal. That gives plenty of time to know if the product will hold up against use.
8 Best Yogurt Maker Reviews
To find the perfect yogurt maker, we looked at the features, benefits, ratings and reviews of multiple options. Ultimately, we chose the following eight yogurt makers to be the best based on their heating and cooling features, their capacity, their convenience, and their designs.
What You Will Love: You can make up to 50 ounces of yogurt at once.
The Cuisinart CYM-100 Electronic Yogurt Maker with Automatic Cooling is very simple to use. Place your ingredients inside, cover, and plug it in.
It automatically sets to an 8 hour fermentation setting, but it can be altered for times from one hour to 24 hours.
When the timer goes off, the unit switches to automatic cooling where it will stay until you unplug it. All of the non-electrical parts are dishwasher safe. It has a stainless steel design and a 3 year warranty.
Often, the heating element will burn out very quickly. Unfortunately, the three year warranty is not full, so you may find yourself paying at least a portion for replacement parts.
- Mostly dishwasher safe,
- Easy to use,
- Easy to read lcd display screen,
- Automatic cooling.
- 3 year warranty,
- Easy to alter fermentation timer,
- Makes up to 50 ounces of yogurt in one go,
- Stainless steel design
- Three year warranty will likely cost you,
- Heating element often goes out over time
What You Will Love: You can make seven different yogurt flavors at once.
With the Euro Cuisine YM80 Yogurt Maker’s clear lid, you can view the cooking process. It comes with seven 6 ounce jars that have separate lids.
This means that you can make seven different flavors at once. Even better, the jars are dishwasher safe for easy clean up when your yogurt is ready. The remainder of the product is BPA free.
This yogurt maker gives you control of the sweetness level, ingredients, yogurt thickness, and fat. Your yogurt can be ready in 6 to 10 hours- depending on the thickness of the yogurt you desire.
Additionally, it automatically shuts off after 15 hours of use, in case it has been forgotten. It comes with a three year warranty. Though it has a cute design, it might take up a large amount of your counter space.
However, this handy kitchen tool will usually run under $50, giving you a lot of bang for your buck. At that price, it just might be worth the counter space.
- 12 adjustable power setting,
- Cute design,
- Three year warranty,
- 7- 6 oz. Jars that are dishwasher safe,
- Up to 42 ounces of yogurt at once, on/off switch, indicator light,
- Bpa free,
- Very budget friendly
- Takes a lot of space,
- It may also get too hot
Runner-Up (Best Budget with LCD Display)
What You Will Love: It has a small and compact design that is even more compact thanks to its ability to store all of the accessories in the unit.
The Dash Greek Yogurt Maker is a small and compact unit with the ability to make up to 2 qts of Greek yogurt in 8- 12 hours.
When the yogurt has finished cooking, you can store it in the two included BPA storage containers with lids. It also includes a one year warranty, strainer basket, and recipe book.
When the unit is not in use, you can easily store all of the accessories inside of it before putting it away.
Additionally, it comes with a hidden cord and in multiple color options. It is easy to operate and the LCD display is easy to see. The only downside to the product is that it is limited to Greek yogurt.
With all of these benefits and extra goodies, you would expect it to put a nice little hole in your wallet. Surprisingly, you can usually find it between $55 and $65, which is quite the bargain.
- Fair price,
- Multiple color options,
- Lcd display,
- Hidden cord,
- One year warranty,
- Two bpa free storage containers with lids,
- Dishwasher safe,
- Compact and lightweight,
- Easy to store,
- Strainer basket and recipe book included
- Limited to Greek yogurt
Best Electric Yogurt Maker
What You Will Love: It has a basic design yet surpasses the more elegant designs in many ways.
Though the Yogourmet 104 Electric Yogurt Maker has a basic design, that does not affect the quality. It is, quite possibly, the best Greek yogurt maker available.
This yogurt maker usersa water bath method that keeps the temperature at an optimal level for yogurt making.
The container in which the yogurt is made comes with a seal-tight lid, meaning that you can store the yogurt in the same container for up to three weeks. Additionally, that container is dishwasher safe so it is preventing extra mess.
The consistent temperature produces up to 2 qts. of yogurt in about four and a half hours, and the texture of the yogurt is something to brag about.
You can use the included thermometer to check your yogurt’s temperature. The price may be a bit high for some budgets, and some users have complained about encountering water leaks with their unit.
- Basic design,
- Can produce two quarts in approximately four hours,
- Yogurt can be stored in the container it’s made in for up to 3 weeks,
- Comes with thermometer,
- Water bath method provides consistent optimal temperature,
- Dishwasher safe containers
- Some complaints of water leakage,
Best Manual Yogurt Maker
What You Will Love: It comes with containers for making both large and small batches.
The Oster Mykonos Greek Manual Yogurt Maker comes with six 7 ounce glass jars and one 17 ounce plastic container, giving you the versatility of different batch sizes.
As it is made for Greek yogurt, it is no surprise that the included strainer gives you the ability to turn regular yogurt into Greek yogurt.
When the unit is not in use, all of the included accessories fit inside it for easy storage.
With so many positive components, it seems like a pretty perfect manual yogurt maker, but there are a couple of problems. First is that because it is manual, the user will have to do more work.
Second is that the included plastic jar lids are not very durable, so it would be wise to have some extra on hand. Finally, at over $50, it may not be feasible for all budgets.
- Great for both small and large batches,
- Easy to store,
- Easy to use,
- Versatile abilities
- Manual means more work for you,
- Plastic jar lids may break easily
Best Stainless Steel Yogurt Maker
What You Will Love: The insert is designed to preserves nutrients and enzymes, and the yogurt maker can also be a slow cooker.
The VitaClay VS7600-2C 2-in-1 Yogurt Maker is both great as a Greek yogurt maker, and multi functions as a slow cooker.
The clay insert is not only designed to preserve the healthy items, but is also lead free, chemical free, and easy to clean.
Along with the glass lid, you can simply store your yogurt in it and refrigerate, though you will want to transfer the yogurt to a container in a reasonable timeframe.
The stainless steel housing makes it a more attractive yogurt maker. Though it is easy to operate, many users find that it takes longer to produce yogurt than most other models.
- Good price,
- Lead free and chemical free lead insert,
- Removable insert and glass lid- easy to clean and refrigerate,
- Great for large greek yogurt batches,
- Three temperature settings,
- Stainless steel housing,
- Also serves as a slow cooker,
- Simple to operate
- Takes longer to produce yogurt than other models
Best Large Yogurt Maker
What You Will Love: It comes with seven 6 oz. jars that have strong lids for storage.
The Euro Cuisine YM100 Automatic Yogurt Maker is a handy kitchen appliance for any yogurt maker that likes to control the sweetness and texture of their yogurt.
It includes seven 6 oz. lids that allow you to make seven flavors at once. Additionally, these jars come with strong lids, so you can simply transfer the jars to the refrigerator.
Thanks to the auto-shut off feature, you can set it and forget it while you complete other daily tasks. The plastic components are BPA free and dishwasher safe.
It also comes with a three year warranty. At such a budget friendly price, you would think there are no complaints. Mostly, there is not but the one common complaint is that it takes up a good amount of counter space.
- Automatic shut off after 15 hours,
- Bpa free,
- Three year warranty,
- Seven 6 oz containers,
- Strong lids,
- Mostly dishwasher safe,
- Can view process and progress through plastic lid,
- Budget friendly
- Takes a good amount of counter space
Best Small Yogurt Maker
What You Will Love: Its internal container is great for frozen yogurt as well since it is freezer safe.
Though small in stature, the Salton YM9 1-Quart Yogurt Maker is a mighty home yogurt machine. It can make one quart of your favorite yogurt in 4 to 10 hours.
As the internal container is freezer safe and has an air tight lid, your yogurt can be stored for up to two weeks in it straight from the yogurt machine. Its small size makes it perfect for those who lack a lot of space, and make small amounts of yogurt at a time.
The small size and built-in power cord storage make it easy to store. It is temperature controlled, lightweight, and easy to use. The included recipe book can assist both newbies and seasoned yogurt makers find new tastes to love.
The only downside, really, might be the price. It is a bit high but still less expensive than most other options.
- Small and compact,
- Easy to store,
- Easy to use,
- Container is fridge and freezer safe,
- Temperature controlled,
- Lightweight, included recipe book
- Price a bit high
In this article, we have taken a look at two types of yogurt makers, the benefits of each, and options in both categories.
Although choosing one yogurt maker in a sea of great options can be overwhelming, the guidelines in this review can help you decide on the best yogurt maker for you.
- Crepe Maker Buying Guide
- Best Egg Cooker Reviews
- Best Electric Pasta Maker Option For Great Pasta
- More Kitchen Accessories Buying Guide
- Most Essential Small Electric Appliance Buying Guides